84% for Debt, Just 16% for Everything Else: What Future Is Pakistan Building?

84% for Debt, Just 16% for Everything Else: What Future Is Pakistan Building?

The Audit Report on the Accounts of Federal Government (Civil), Audit Year 2025–26, presented before the National Assembly under Article 171 of the Constitution, exposes an alarming picture of Pakistan’s federal finances. During FY2024–25, approximately 84.31 per cent of total federal expenditure went towards debt servicing, leaving barely 15.69 per cent for all other federal responsibilities. This is not simply an accounting statistic; it is a reflection of the financial predicament confronting a nation of more than 240 million people.

According to the report, total federal expenditure reached Rs41.336 trillion against a final approved budget of Rs39.345 trillion, exceeding the allocation by Rs1.991 trillion. Of this expenditure, Rs34.852 trillion went towards debt servicing, including Rs8.998 trillion in interest payments and Rs25.853 trillion in repayment of loan principal. The remaining Rs6.484 trillion had to meet all other federal responsibilities. Even more disturbing, public debt contributed approximately Rs32.766 trillion, or 76.40 per cent, of total federal receipts.

The consequences are reflected in public-service allocations. Health accounted for only 0.18 per cent of total expenditure, education 0.44 per cent and social protection 1.47 per cent. How can Pakistan aspire to a prosperous future when investment in its people remains so constrained?

The audit findings expose serious weaknesses in financial management and parliamentary oversight. Supplementary grants amounting to Rs3,177.682 billion were not placed before the National Assembly for approval, raising constitutional concerns under Article 84. The report also identifies Rs187.680 billion in expenditure beyond final grants without supplementary approval.

Furthermore, an unjustified budget demand of Rs3,809.190 billion was identified, of which Rs3,644.804 billion was subsequently surrendered or reappropriated across 841 cost centres. Another Rs87.336 billion remained unutilized across 115 cost centres. The report also identifies 28,427 cases of missing General Provident Fund subscription credits. These findings raise serious questions about planning, financial discipline and accountability. How can departments claim inadequate resources while substantial allocations remain unutilized?

Against this background, the government’s much-publicized URAAN Pakistan programme deserves a reality check. Its objectives include increasing exports, promoting digital development, strengthening energy and infrastructure, environmental sustainability and social empowerment. These are worthy ambitions, but where will the resources come from?

How can Pakistan transform its economy, improve education and healthcare, expand exports and create employment when more than 84 per cent of federal expenditure is consumed by debt servicing? The government continues to make ambitious claims about URAAN Pakistan and economic transformation. Presenting a vision without addressing financial realities is little more than political publicity. What a joke!

The Prime Minister’s recent prediction that Pakistan could become the world’s sixth-largest economy before 2050 also deserves scrutiny. Mr Prime Minister, how can we promise such an extraordinary future when today’s financial realities tell a very different story? Should the government not first demonstrate how it will rescue the economy in 2026 before making ambitious promises about 2050? A vision for 2050 must begin with credible performance today, not political optimism.

Pakistan has witnessed numerous economic programmes and national visions. The problem has never been a shortage of attractive slogans; it has been the absence of consistent implementation, institutional accountability and political commitment. Economic stabilization is important, but it is not economic development. The country urgently needs to broaden its tax base, eliminate wasteful expenditure, improve public-sector performance and promote agriculture, industry, technology and exports rather than continuing its dependence on borrowing.

Parliament must exercise its constitutional oversight responsibilities seriously. Audit objections should not disappear into official files. The Public Accounts Committee must ensure investigations, fix responsibility and recover public money wherever necessary. Every ministry should be assessed on measurable results rather than simply the amount it spends.

The latest Auditor-General’s report should be treated as a national warning. It exposes a system in which debt obligations dominate national priorities while essential public services struggle for resources.

The question Pakistan must confront is simple: Are we building an economy for future generations, or borrowing against their future to pay for our past?

A nation cannot mortgage the dreams of its children to finance the failures of its rulers. Every rupee lost to mismanagement, every opportunity sacrificed to debt and every promise left unfulfilled is a burden passed on to generations yet unborn. Pakistan’s children deserve classrooms, hospitals, employment and hope—not an endless inheritance of loans and liabilities.

The real measure of leadership is not how confidently a Prime Minister predicts Pakistan’s future in 2050, but what kind of Pakistan today’s leaders leave behind. Our people deserve a future of dignity and opportunity, not a lifetime of debt.

Dr Alamdar Hussain Malik
Advisor Academics, University of Veterinary and Animal Sciences, Swat
Former Financial Advisor, Finance Division, Government of Pakistan

Leave a Reply

You cannot copy content of this page